top of page

The Case of the Disappearing Results

6 days ago
6 min read

You lost the weight. You followed the diet. You even bought smaller clothes. So why did the results disappear? And what exactly did you lose in the first place?



The Mystery


The evidence looked convincing.

The scale was down eight kilograms.

Clothes fitted better.

Friends and colleagues had noticed.


After years of unsuccessful attempts, it seemed that the weight-loss problem had finally been solved.


Until, several months later, the numbers began climbing again. The smaller clothes became uncomfortable. The familiar frustration returned. And once again, the search began.


Another diet. Another programme. Another promise.


But before investigating the next weight-loss breakthrough, perhaps we should examine the scene of the previous one.


Because there are two questions that rarely receive enough attention.


What exactly did you lose?

And why did the results not last?


Clue No. 1: The scale wasn't telling the whole story


Eight kilograms lost.


An impressive result!


But eight kilograms of what?


The human body consists of more than fat. Water, muscle, organs, bone and other tissues all contribute to body weight.


When you lose weight, the scale cannot distinguish between them.


A change in eating habits, particularly carbohydrate and overall food intake, can alter the amount of glycogen and associated water stored in your body.


This can contribute to rapid changes in scale weight.


Over a longer period, weight loss may include both fat and fat-free tissue. Preserving muscle becomes especially important.


So, although the scale showed eight kilograms less, it could not tell us how much unnecessary fat had actually been lost. That required more evidence.


Changes in waist measurements, body composition, strength, clothing fit and other relevant indicators can help us build a more useful picture of progress.


The first clue had revealed something important.


Losing weight and improving body composition are not necessarily the same thing.


Clue No. 2: The prime suspect was willpower


The next question seemed straightforward.


Why did the weight return?


The usual suspect was already waiting.


Willpower.


After all, the diet had worked when the rules were followed. Then life became complicated. A meeting ran late. Lunch was skipped. A restaurant invitation interrupted the meal plan. There was a holiday, a stressful week, a weekend that went differently from what was intended.


Gradually, the diet became harder to follow. Eventually, the old eating habits returned.


Case closed?


Not quite.


There was something this explanation overlooked.


This person had already demonstrated considerable determination. They had counted calories, restricted foods, followed fasting schedules and committed to demanding exercise routines. For weeks, sometimes months, they had followed the instructions. So perhaps the more useful question wasn't simply why they stopped following the diet.


Why had the way they were eating become so difficult to sustain?


Clue No. 3: What was actually on the plate?


Now the investigation becomes interesting.


Imagine examining a typical day's eating.


Breakfast might be little more than coffee. Lunch might be a small salad, selected because it seemed like the healthiest option. By late afternoon, hunger has become difficult to ignore. Dinner becomes the largest meal of the day, followed perhaps by something sweet. The next morning, the response is familiar.


Eat less.


Be stricter.


Make up for yesterday.


But what if the investigation had started with a different question?


Was the person eating enough of the right food to meet their nutritional needs while working towards fat loss? Was there adequate protein?

Were meals sufficiently nourishing and satisfying? Were portions appropriate? Were some foods being avoided unnecessarily?


And were other foods, chosen because they appeared healthy, being consumed in quantities that did not support the intended outcome?


Healthy food choices and appropriate food quantities are not automatically the same thing.


Eating too little can make hunger harder to manage.


Eating more energy than the body requires can prevent fat loss, even when the food itself is nutritious.


Both quality and quantity matter.


And both need to be considered in the context of the individual.


Clue No. 4: The soft drink that was suddenly forgotten


Something happened recently during a Maria-E coaching session that illustrates why I look beyond individual foods and drinks.


A client had been consuming large quantities of a particular soft drink. She had felt she couldn't go without it. I used my 70/90 Method™ to develop personalised eating guidelines, drawing on my training, experience and assessment of her individual needs. Her soft-drink consumption formed part of those guidelines.


During our second follow-up, in her second week of coaching, we were discussing her progress.


Suddenly, she stopped.


She looked up at me, visibly shocked.


She had just realised that she hadn't consumed the soft drink for more than three days.


She hadn't been counting the days. She simply hadn't felt like having it. And until that moment, she hadn't even noticed. This was a meaningful discovery for someone who had previously felt unable to go without the drink.


It doesn't establish precisely why her desire had changed. A single experience cannot tell us which nutritional or behavioural factors were responsible.


But it raises an interesting question.


What happens when we stop focusing exclusively on the foods and drinks someone struggles with, and start examining how they are eating as a whole?


Sometimes, the evidence worth investigating is not simply what somebody has stopped consuming.


It is how their eating behaviour is changing.


Clue No. 5: The missing skill


There was still another question to investigate.


Even when someone understands which foods to eat and how much they need, can they consistently make those decisions in everyday life?


Can they plan and prepare meals without relying on a rigid menu?


Can they choose an appropriate meal when work becomes chaotic?


Can they enjoy a restaurant dinner and return to their normal eating rhythm afterwards?


Can they recognise when something isn't working and make a useful adjustment instead of abandoning everything?


These are skills.


They develop through learning, experience, observation and correction.


And they matter because life rarely unfolds exactly as planned. This is where I see the value of teaching people how to eat, rather than simply giving them another diet to follow.


Not perfectly.


Not according to an endless collection of rules.


But well enough, consistently enough, to support their goals over time.


A new suspect enters the investigation: GLP-1 medications


Today, medications such as Wegovy and Mounjaro are changing weight-management treatment. For appropriately selected patients, these treatments can produce clinically meaningful weight loss. They can also help regulate appetite, which may make reducing food intake easier. But they don't eliminate the importance of understanding someone's nutritional needs, body composition, medical circumstances and everyday eating behaviour.


And weight maintenance remains an important consideration.


In the STEP 1 trial extension, participants regained, on average, approximately two-thirds of their previous weight loss during the year after semaglutide and the structured lifestyle intervention were discontinued. That finding doesn't mean the medication failed. Obesity can require long-term medical management, and medication may be an important component of that treatment.


It does, however, remind us that achieving weight loss and maintaining it are two separate challenges. So before selecting another intervention, whether a diet, a programme or medication, there is value in understanding exactly what needs to change and what support may be required to sustain the result.


The case isn't closed by another diet


The investigation has uncovered several possibilities.


Perhaps part of the initial weight loss was water rather than fat.


Perhaps the eating approach was too restrictive to maintain.


Perhaps the food was not meeting the person's nutritional needs.


Perhaps portions, hunger, sleep, activity, medical factors or everyday eating habits were contributing.


Often, more than one factor is involved.


The answer will not be identical for everyone.


This is precisely why investigation matters. At Maria-E, my focus is on helping clients improve body composition, not simply chase a smaller number on the scale.


That means working towards four objectives:


  • Losing unnecessary fat intelligently.

  • Preserving muscle.

  • Protecting health.

  • Fuelling everyday performance.


Real food, of the right quality and in quantities appropriate for the individual, is central to that approach. So is learning how to make sound eating decisions independently, even when life doesn't go according to plan.


The goal isn't to spend the rest of your life following instructions.


It is to develop an approach to eating that you understand, can apply and can sustain.


The final question


There will always be another weight-loss breakthrough.


Another diet.


Another technology.


Another treatment.


Some will offer genuine advances. But if you have spent years losing and regaining weight, perhaps the next question should not be: What should I try next?


Perhaps it should be: Do I actually understand what has been preventing me from achieving and maintaining the results I want?


Before choosing another solution, investigate the problem.


Know what is getting in the way.

Change what matters.

See the difference.


— Janine, Maria-E

Fuel Better. Feel Better. Live Better.

 

 
 
 
bottom of page